11 Comments

"Just like the whole phenomenon of Russian racism and nazism, it can be traced to the Soviet years."

...or to an even older tradition of the "Black Hundreds".

A bit of a side note, but the Russian tactic of pointing to Western racism in response to any criticism of their own discriminatory policies dates back to the tsarist times. The infamous "And you are lynching Negroes" card was first played by Tsar's diplomats when Russia faced worldwide ostracism following the Kishinev pogrom.

Obviously racism in the West is still an issue and was even more so over a century ago, but it doesn't make this form of whataboutism any less dishonest.

Expand full comment
May 9, 2023·edited May 9, 2023

"if you call him, you should use vocativus: “o skinheadye!”."

No, you shouldn't. Unlike Polish, Russian doesn't have a real vocative case. There is something called the "old vocative", but it's limited to a few fixed expressions, e.g. "Bozhe!" or "Gospodi!" ("[oh my] God!"). There is also the "new vocative", but again it is limited to certain types of words, such as people's names (e.g. if you are colloquially addressing a girl called Lena, you can say "Len!").

Expand full comment

Sorry, Monday morning and I'm looking for common sense on the internet, so I come here...

Formally speaking, Russia did not have slavery, as formally slavery is distinguished by the possibility of an individual human purchase/sale transaction. In the Russian case, it was possible to buy people living in an area (assigned to the property being bought), but not an individual slave.

Expand full comment